boy_reading_bibleWhat do you do when you know what is right, but the rules forbid it?

This question is the center of today’s Gospel passage in which Jesus is, according to Mark’s account, somewhat entrapped by the Pharisees, who are apparently looking for any excuse to silence and get rid of him. The motive of the onlookers is made plain: “They watched closely… so that they might accuse him.” The priorities of God in Jesus and priorities of those concerned with maintaining the status quo clearly surface.

Jesus entered the synagogue.
There was a man there who had a withered hand.
They watched Jesus closely
to see if he would cure him on the sabbath
so that they might accuse him.
He said to the man with the withered hand,
“Come up here before us.”
Then he said to the Pharisees,
“Is it lawful to do good on the sabbath rather than to do evil,
to save life rather than to destroy it?”
But they remained silent.
Looking around at them with anger
and grieved at their hardness of heart,
Jesus said to the man, “Stretch out your hand.”
He stretched it out and his hand was restored.
The Pharisees went out and immediately took counsel
with the Herodians against him to put him to death.
(Mark 3:1-6)

What is interesting about this passage is the starting points of both Jesus and the onlooking Pharisees. It’s easy to look at scenario and, with the 20/20 hindsight of Mark’s narrative, quickly castigate the Pharisees for their lack of sensitivity, their misguided prioritization of law over person, and the ostensible plotting that leads to their desire to entrap Jesus. However, these were religious leaders of the age trying to do what they thought was right.

Given the benefit of the doubt, the Pharisees, in their concern for the proper observance of the Sabbath, were striving not to protect their own laws but those of God. For, as any good Jew or Christian should intuitively know, the Decalogue (the Ten Commandments) contains this command from God to keep holy the Sabbath. These religious leaders likely thought that they were doing the right thing, that they were simply obeying the desire of God and exhorting others to do likewise.

It is also easy for us to look at the scenario and see that Jesus is the Word-made-flesh as we, in faith, proclaim, thereby anachronistically trumping the Pharisees’ interpretation of the Torah. For who would know the law of God better than God?

There is an uneasy conflict here. God, in Jesus Christ, is rejected no less for the actualization of God’s law in the most authentic manner by those who at-the-same-time strive, in the name of the same law, to protect that structure for living. The key here, the condition for the very possibility of this rejection and conflict, arises in the subtle, unconscious, and even sincere misplacement of priorities.

So often religious leaders and all people of faith can mistake the human interpretations of God’s law, God’s rules for authentic human living, for God’s command itself. This happened and was called out by Jesus Christ in the First Century, and it happens and is occasionally called out today.

Who someone is supposed to love, how someone is to relate to others, what sort of work or ministry someone is supposed to do, who can or cannot participate in what ways in the life of the faith community, and so on, these remain examples of human interpretations of God’s law and desire even today.

What does it mean when Jesus breaks the rules? Is this a clarion cry for all women and men of faith to engage in ecclesiastical disobedience? No, I don’t think so. It’s not a wildcard justification or a blank check to justify whatever view we wish to espouse or action we wish to pursue.

When Jesus broke the rules as he did in today’s Gospel, he did so to point out what God’s priorities really are: “Do Good…Save Life.” These must always take priority.

Marginalization, discrimination, violence, hatred, and so forth, even dressed up in the sheep’s clothing of legal righteousness and religious zeal, are nevertheless indications that the priorities of God are being supplanted by the personal or collective interests of human beings. One only has to look to Jesus, the fullness of God’s self-disclosure and the very exegesis of God, to find example after example of what Divine priority really looks like.

When Jesus broke the rules, he always did so for the sake of the other and never for his own personal gain. Nothing summarizes this truth better than the crosses we affix to walls and churches and chains around our necks. God does not care about our justifications for the unjust rules that some so passionately defend. God only desires that we “Do Good” and “Save Life,” even if it means breaking the rules.

Photo: Stock


  1. Fr. Dan,
    Very interesting. Would like to have you expound briefly at some point about ecclesiastical disobedience and individual conscience. Certainly food for thought here — enough for a dissertation, but perhaps you could synthesize the subject for the guidance of some confused lay persons.
    Great interpretation of Mark 3:1-6. Thank you.

  2. Wonderful question, not just for religious types, but for people in the workplace who struggle what is right according to their belief in the Christ. When to speak and when to be quiet.

  3. Perhaps this is why those who engage(d) in civil disobedience in the struggle for peace and justice traditionally engage in prayer and retreat before their ‘”action”. I remember this so well from my days at Marquette in the 60’s and I know the tradition is still honored today!

  4. Very thought provoking reflection.

    Just out of curiosity, I was hoping you could provide a specific example from today, where in your opinion “people mistake the human interpretations of God’s law, God’s rules for authentic human living, for God’s command itself.”


    1. I second Michael Foley’s idea. It would be very helpful to have a specific example (or examples) of “people mistake the human interpretation….” I alluded to that in my first comment. Thank you, Fr. Dan.

  5. Dan, Wonderful article. Our human interpretations of the law become the rules. If I understand correctly, Jesus may have broke the rules but did not break God’s laws.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s