Archive for Gun Control

Lessons on Gun Control from ‘Down Under’

Posted in Social Justice, Uncategorized with tags , , , , , on January 17, 2013 by Daniel P. Horan, OFM

johnhowardIn these days following the initial presentation of President Obama’s encouraging agenda to help curb the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction in the form of firearms, there is a lot of talk about the pros and cons, the challenges and the need to make this sort of change happen. Today’s New York Times includes a guest op-ed piece by the former Prime Minister of Australia, John Howard, who — in what I think is a humble and generous way — offers the United States a model to consider while moving forward in the discussion about the banning of assault weapons.

As a Christian, this is a “no-brainer.” Nobody has a right to an assault weapon. Period. Furthermore, as the Roman Catholic Church has continually expressed in recent decades (see, for example, my essay: “Catholic Church on Gun Control: No Firearms for Civilians!” in the book Franciscan Spirituality for the 21st Century: Selected Reflections from the Dating God Blog and Other Essays [2013]), individual citizens should not have access to instruments of murder. Yes, there are circumstances for which a hunter’s rifle, a far cry from assault weapons or handguns which are only used to kill other people, can be justified for the purposes of survival. However, other weapons have no such claim and secondary justifications, such as “for collecting purposes,” remain wholly specious.

Prime Minister Howard offers some interesting observations and commentary, noting along the way the unique hurdles that makes similar change in the US particularly challenging. Nevertheless, it is worth exploring this experience in Australia so that, eventually, we too might be able to say about our nation what the Australians say about their experience of banning assault weapons. Or, as Prime Minister Howard puts it: “Few Australians would deny that their country is safer today as a consequence of gun control.”

To read the op-ed piece, go to: “I Went After Guns. Obama Can, Too.”

Photo: Wire

Christians and Guns: Where Do You Stand?

Posted in Uncategorized with tags , , , , , on February 12, 2011 by Daniel P. Horan, OFM

This is a theme I’ve addressed elsewhere in another blog post shortly after the tragic shooting in Tucson last month. It is a topic I have returned to because of a Catholic News Service article that was published today bearing the title, “In Gun Control Debate, Catholic Position Elusive.” The subheading of the story reads, “One gun-carrying priest: ‘I tell people all life is sacred, including mine.’” That should give you a sense of why this is a matter worth discussing again.

The February 11th CNS article begins:

Avid outdoorsman and hunter Fr. Joe Classen, associate pastor at Holy Spirit Parish in Maryland Heights, Mo., has a permit to carry a concealed weapon.

“I rarely ever conceal and carry, but sometimes if I’m in a very bad area, I do take protection,” he said. “I tell people all life is sacred, including mine.”

A few states away, Fr. Theodore Parker said he knows he has the constitutional right to own a gun, but can’t see any reason why he would. The pastor of two inner-city Detroit parishes said, “The real purpose of a gun in our culture is violence.” And there’s just too much of that, he contends.

As readers of this blog know, I agree with the position of the second interviewed priest, Fr. Parker, and take it a step further — a step that, according to a January 14 CNS article titled, “Gun control: Church firmly, quietly opposes firearms for civilians,” is clearly in line with the Church’s teaching, no matter how “elusive” it may appear to Fr. Classen and others.

Guns are designed to do one thing: kill. Granted, there are instances such as hunting at which times civilians might justifiably use a firearm to gather food. However, there are other ways one can find nourishment today and some people would even suggest that one need not even hunt to eat healthily, just ask a vegetarian or vegan. Apart from hunting animals for food, the only thing guns are good for are killing human beings.

Fr. Classen defends his ownership, concealment and carrying of a firearm in “very bad areas” for “protection.” In what way does he intend to use the firearm for protection? The most obvious answer is to kill or harm another human being before that person could ostensibly attempt to harm him. How is that OK? Especially for a priest?

All life is sacred. Period. And to be truly prolife means that one’s life is not worth more than another, not even a priest’s over an alleged criminal’s.

I understand that the issue of self-defense is a complicated and contentious one, where people otherwise committed to nonviolence find examples worthy of exemption. However, when we really turn to the Gospel for guidance in the matter of violence and the role of Christians, can we ever justify the use of violence? Jesus Christ himself submitted, innocent as he was, to the violence of the state and individuals. In the case of self-defense, Jesus chastised his own Apostles for trying to defend him with violence. Jesus did NOT see self-defense as a legitimate reason for violence.

I find it particularly upsetting when priests publicly defend the carrying of weapons. It seems like something that stands in stark contrast to what Christian life is all about. When it comes to guns of any sort, we know What Jesus Would Do.

The world will only be transformed by love, not violence. Maybe instead of carrying a tool of death into “very bad areas,” Fr. Classen could carry a spirit of openness and peace, meeting the people he is scared of with the compassion of Christ and not the violence the Lord condemns. This is especially important if gun-carrying priests like to see themselves as in persona Christi.

Jesus wouldn’t defend guns, why would you?

Catholic Church on Gun Control: No Firearms for Civilians!

Posted in Uncategorized with tags , , , , , , , on January 16, 2011 by Daniel P. Horan, OFM

This reflection is now available in Daniel P. Horan, OFM’s book Franciscan Spirituality for the 21st Century: Selected Reflections from the Dating God Blog and Other Essays, Volume One (Koinonia Press, 2013).

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 390 other followers

%d bloggers like this: